Category Archives: Religion

Saudi’s National Identity

Saudi’s National Identity

“I’m telling you, you can’t compare Saudi Arabia to other countries”

– Al-Waleed bin Talal

The ‘Modern’ Saudi

Saudi Arabia has spent much of the 20th and 21st century asserting a unique form of national identity within the Middle East; one that argues that it is the leader of global Islam and, as such, the spiritual and political head of the Ummah (the Arabic term for the supra-national Islamic world).

This identity, and the need to create this identity, has defined the international relationship Saudi Arabia has had with its neighbours in the Middle East and, although it has managed to give Saudi Arabia some political dominance over the affairs of the Gulf Region and wider world, it has also brought them into direct rivalry with others in the region, in particular Iran, who have a divergent geopolitical vision for the world. This rivalry has never resulted in anything more than proxy conflicts in the past, but Saudi’s continued pursuit of regional political authority may well lead it to conflict in 2016.

The root of its national identity lies in the religious divides that have defined the Islamic World for centuries. Sunni and Shi’a Islam have two opposing interpretations of the religion, rooted in the historical succession to Mohammed, and each have a political proponent in Saudi Arabia and Iran respectively. This rivalry is greater than a simple difference of opinion and it has resulted in the deaths of hundreds of thousands. It has created an intractable conflict between two religious identities that, in the modern world, has divided communities as much as it has divided nation states.

Across the Middle East there is now a split between Sunni and Shi’a communities. Iraq, Bahrain, Syria and Saudi Arabia are all split along sectarian lines and whilst Iraq and Syria have descended into violence, Saudi Arabia has managed to contain its own sectarian struggles. However, through its decision to intervene militarily in Syria and Yemen, through its suppression of Shi’a opponents (culminating in the execution of 41 prisoners) and through its continued aggression towards Iran, it has risked its future stability.

In Yemen the Saudi led coalition has targeted Houthi rebels in a war that has pitched the Shi’a rebels (characterised by Saudi Arabia as terrorists) against the ‘saviour’ of Sunni Islam. It has become a nationalist struggle and signals a new period in Saudi Arabia’s military strength, in which it is prepared to commit troops to wars abroad. This all  symbolises the ‘new’ Saudi Arabia which is focused on its preeminent role in Middle Eastern affairs.

However, this new foreign policy agenda is provocative. Saudi nationalism has come at the price of Middle Eastern security. It has led to protests from its own Shi’a minority in the East who are seeking greater representation in politics and want to challenge the authority of the ruling Saud family. This resentment from its Shi’a minority has been brutally repressed by the Saudi regime and many of the individuals executed in the most recent round of government ‘justice’ were protestors who argued against government policies.

The restriction of free press has become a part of the new Saudi national identity. It sees the Gulf Region as the centre of a vast battle between the two sides of Islam and with its political future staked on wining this battle against Iran, it cannot allow any threats to go unnoticed.  Protest and political criticism is the biggest threat to Saudi Arabia’s stability.

So what could a potential future for Saudi Arabia entail?

If Saudi Arabia continues its pursuit of a supra-national Sunni identity it will come into conflict with Iran. The Sunni-Shi’a split is arguably the most ingrained division in politics, based on thousands of years of history, and it will not be solved simply. When this religious divide is combined with the geopolitical conflict between the Saudi and Iranian desire for regional dominance, the potential for conflict is vast. The two nations are already entrenched in conflicts around the region, supporting opposing sides (although neither side supports Islamic State, despite seeing alternative ways in which to end the conflict) and these positions have already resulted in political controversy, from accusations of supplying weapons to claims that air raids have been used to target political, as well as military, targets.

From here the potential for face-to-face conflict is very real. Saudi Arabia and Iran have begun an escalation of tensions that, unstopped, would only lead to open warfare. This war would be a war for regional dominance and for economic and political superiority. It would determine the future of many other nations in the region, such as Syria and Iraq, and, most importantly, it would confirm who had authority of the Ummah and thus the Islamic world.

By Peter Banham

Is Argentina Being Left Behind?

Is Argentina Being Left Behind?

Argentina has been left reeling this week after a political scandal engulfed the government. Alberto Nisman, a renowned Argentinian lawyer, investigating the 1994 bombing of a Jewish centre in Buenos Aires, was found dead last week. He had caused great controversy by arguing that the Argentinian government has continually covered up Iran’s involvement in the attack. Many believe that his death is not only suspicious but is likely to have been a politically motivated murder aiming to destabilise the case he was building against the government, or indeed to destabilise the government itself. Continue Reading

Zoroaster, Yazidis and the Modern Middle East

Zoroaster, Yazidis and the Modern Middle East

Before Islam emerged across the Middle East there were ancient religions that dominated Middle Eastern culture. These included Zoroastrianism. This ancient Persian religion follows the teachings on the prophet, Zoroaster, whose notions of duality created a religion that has been deemed heretical over the centuries. In the modern world Zoroastrianism does not have the global reach it once had, but it is still present and still facing the same struggles with Islam that it did over 1000 years ago. On the mountains of Northern Iraq the Yazidis (ideological inheritors of Zoroastrian traditions) are under continual attack from the militants of the Islamic State. Continue Reading

Beyond the Hotel – Trinidad, Paradise and Politics

Beyond the Hotel – Trinidad, Paradise and Politics

behind the ‘paradise’ exterior of Trinidad there is a violent undercurrent of fundamental politics. Nationalism, fundamental Islam, socialism and crime combine in parts of the Caribbean to create a nation that diverges greatly from our perceived notion of these islands. Ultimately the beaches and hotels only part describe the Caribbean and the reality is that the politics of this region reveal the Caribbean, if only we can go beyond the hotel. Continue Reading

Iraq Three Ways – Iraq’s Sectarian Splits

Iraq Three Ways – Iraq’s Sectarian Splits

Iraq is one of the world’s oldest nations. It was here that civilisation first emerged around the shores of the Tigris and, as such, it is in Iraq that some of the world’s oldest divisions occur. These divisions are blighting the modern state, causing a sectarian conflict that has the potential to rip apart the Iraqi state and create, in its wake, three very different and distinct states. Continue Reading

Christianity and its Troubled Relationship with the Chinese State

Christianity and its Troubled Relationship with the Chinese State

China is a communist state. This is a fact known worldwide, but within the state this single fact impinges on every aspect of the lives of its citizens. For China’s Christian population this communist ideology has put them at odds with China’s government. Under communist ideology there is no space for religion. Religion promotes a life code and set of beliefs that differentiates from the traditions established by the government. Continue Reading

“There is no need for…

“There is no need for…

“There is no need for temples, no need for complicated philosophies. My brain and my heart are my temples; my philosophy is kindness”. Tenzin Gyasto, Dalai Lama (Tibetan Buddhist Leader, 1950-Present) Some inspirational words of wisdom from the Dalai Lama to start our Far East Season on A Little View of the World Continue Reading

Pakistan, Narendra Modi and the Sub-Continent

Pakistan, Narendra Modi and the Sub-Continent

With one of the most critical elections in India for many years the two sides; the Indian National Congress (with the weight of the powerful Nehru-Gandhi family) and the BJP, lead by the Hindu nationalist, Narendra Modi are ready to do battle at the polls. Critically Pakistan has surprisingly supported Modi’s bid for power, believing he is a candidate they can work with towards regional peace. The geopolitics of this declaration are profound. Continue Reading

The Insurgency Still Tearing Apart the Philippines

The Insurgency Still Tearing Apart the Philippines

The Philippines is a fractured state; the Earth’s tectonic activity has seen to that, but amongst the myriad of islands lie the roots of an internal conflict that has torn apart the nation. This conflict is one of the oldest, ongoing military struggles in the world today, having started in 1942 during the confusion of World War II. However, the conflict has faded in the global conscience and the focus of Filipino discourse has shifted towards its economic development Continue Reading

The ‘Man from Buenos Aires’: How an Argentinian Pope Will Affect Latin America

The ‘Man from Buenos Aires’: How an Argentinian Pope Will Affect Latin America

For the first time in history the Papacy is to be run by a Latin American Pope. This article looks at the impact on Latin America and in particular Argentina (Pope Francis’s homeland) of the new era in Papal politics. Issues, such as the power of the Catholic Church of Latin America, social inequality and the image of Argentina and Latin America across the world, are all discussed and we look at how important and Argentinian Pope could be for world politics. Continue Reading

Religious Authority vs Secular Leadership: How Religious Leaders Work in a Modern Framework

Religious Authority vs Secular Leadership: How Religious Leaders Work in a Modern Framework

Combining the role of religious authority with a political role is incredibly difficult in the modern world, particularly in regions where the nations do not define themselves as religious, but where secularism and democratic principles have become the way to determine political policies. Some such as the Iranian Ayatollah have managed to establish a hybrid of religious and political governance in nations which are still perceived as religious states. However other leaders such as the Pope and the Dalai Lama have seen their role change in world politics from one that dictates political action to one of moral and spiritual authority. Continue Reading

Is Central Asia Threatened by Rising Islamic Power?

Is Central Asia Threatened by Rising Islamic Power?

Islamic Orthodoxy has become increasingly prevalent in both Central Asia and the Middle East and this has meant that the cultural traditions of the ‘West’ and many other non-Islamic communities are under threat. Traditions, such as those at Christmas, New Year etc are being discouraged by Islamic governments, looking for a purer Islamic state. Continue Reading

Christianity in Egypt: The New Coptic Pope

Christianity in Egypt: The New Coptic Pope

On the 18th November the new Coptic Pope was enthroned in Egypt. Pope Tawadros II has been selected by the Coptic Church in Egypt as the successor to Pope Shenouda III who died in March, 2012. The new Pope has inherited responsibility over a community who are currently facing a crisis over the future of their culture and religion in a nation which is becoming increasingly Islamic. Continue Reading

The New Frontiers for Catholicism

The New Frontiers for Catholicism

This week the Catholic Church announced six new saints to join the wider fold of Catholicism and many of the new saintly figures include those on the very fringes of the Catholic world. With the establishment of the first Native American saint we look at how the Church is evolving to deal with an ever changing world. Continue Reading

Islam in Russia: The Growing Caucasus Problem

Islam in Russia: The Growing Caucasus Problem

As the largest nation in the world Russia contains a mixture of cultures and religions and this has pushed certain regions within the country to crisis point where the cultural divides have descended into sectarian violence and it is in the predominantly Islamic areas of Southern Russia, in the Caucasus region, where the violence is most extreme. Continue Reading

Egypt Today (Part 2): The Problems for Minorities in New Islamic Politics

Egypt Today (Part 2): The Problems for Minorities in New Islamic Politics

Egypt, surprisingly, is a nation with significant minorities and these have a critical role to play in forming the new society within Egypt. However with an Islamic leader taking over control of the nation the future of the these groups, largely the Egyptian Coptic community, is uncertain and I assess from a first hand perspective the role of minorities in Egypt. Continue Reading